-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 6.7k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
[opencv3] Upgrade to version 3.4.8 #8623
Conversation
pls can anybody explain why this is not merged yet? |
@vicroms Ready to merge now. |
I lost track of this PR opencv3[contrib] is broken, downloading is not disabled anymore, ocv_update is used in a patch and not through commands passed by the portfile... also I suspect that the dlls/lib are treated in the new way and so some new parameters should be passed to the configure step, something similar to what has already been requested since a long time ago in the opencv4 pr cited above but never done. It looks like I should give up keeping opencv in a proper shape here on vcpkg, because the moment a PR about it is accepted, the moment it is almost surely damaged. @vicroms sorry for ranting, but to be honest my thoughts now are that I might not contribute anymore to vcpkg, at least not without a proper CI in place to check features better, to preserve port quality and to at least guarantee not to regress going on (something that is continuously happening here)
because it was broken, and still was when merged |
Revert "[opencv3] Upgrade to version 3.4.8 (microsoft#8623)" (microsoft#8911)
Hi @cenit, Thanks for your feedback and contributions to vcpkg – you’re one of our most active community members. I'm sorry about the issues with the OpenCV port and moving forward we’re committed to improve the experience and collaboration with our contributors. For now, I've reverted the changes, as in it's current state, this PR regresses OpenCV features. I would like to unblock this update, and as I understand from your comments on this and the related PR (#8557) there are changes that need to be done in the PR and in our CI testing to make sure that no features are regressed. Moving forward, the vcpkg team would like to start a conversation with you and other OpenCV contributors to better understand how we can expand our CI coverage to ensure a higher quality control for further OpenCV upgrades/changes. Also, if you have any feedback for other areas of improvement in vcpkg please feel free to reach me (viromer@microsoft.com) or the team at vcpkg@microsoft.com. We would be glad to receive your insights and opinions. |
Hi there, can you pls solve this and merge? |
i'm very very busy at the moment, sorry, so I cannot guarantee any timing. I can try to push it a little bit up in my stack, but i'd be happier to help reviewing a PR if it happens |
@cenit I will do this job. |
@JackBoosY thanks |
Upgrade opencv3 to version 3.4.8 and fix old patches.
Related opencv4 PR: #8557