Skip to content

Lastmanagement mit 3p = ok, 1p = nok #19166

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom
Closed
2 tasks done
Nasdero opened this issue Feb 25, 2025 · 46 comments · Fixed by #20183
Closed
2 tasks done

Lastmanagement mit 3p = ok, 1p = nok #19166

Nasdero opened this issue Feb 25, 2025 · 46 comments · Fixed by #20183
Assignees
@andig @premultiply
Labels
enhancement New feature or request

Comments

@Nasdero
Copy link

Nasdero commented Feb 25, 2025

Describe the bug

Diskussion war in: #19044

Wir haben in die Zuleitung zur Garage eine Shelly 3EM installiert, da wir in der Garage demnächst den GO-E zur openWB Pro dazu in Betrieb nehmen wollen.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Nun haben wir zum Test in evcc das Lastmanagement auf 16A / 11000W gestellt.

  2. Wenn wir nun mit 1p die Ladung auf Schnell starten an der Pro mit dem ZOE angeschlossen, dann fängt die Ladung mit 32A an und im 2. Zyklus kommt dann eine Meldung und es wir auf ~16A runter geregelt.

  3. Machen wir das selbe mit 3p, dann wird im ersten Zyklus mit 16A angefangen, das passt also.

Configuration details

Konfiguration (/etc/evcc.yaml):

# open evcc at http://evcc.local:7070
network:
  schema: http
  host: debian-server.lan # .local suffix announces the hostname on MDNS
  port: 7070

log: debug
levels:
  cache: error

# unique installation id
plant: *****

interval: 15s # control cycle interval

sponsortoken: *****

database:
  type: sqlite
  dsn: /var/lib/evcc/evcc.db

site:
  meters:
    ext:
      - garage_meter


meters:
  - name: garage_meter
    type: template
    template: shelly-pro-3em
    usage: grid
    host: 192.168.2.56
    
circuits:
  - name: main # eindeutiger Name, wird als Referenz für andere Circuits verwendet
    title: Hauptstromkreis # Anzeige in der UI (später)
    maxCurrent: 50 # 63A (optional)
    maxPower: 34000
    meter: db:11 # optional
  - name: garage
    title: Garage
    maxCurrent: 16
    maxpower: 11000
    parent: main
    meter: garage_meter


charger
---
db:18 type:template {"host":"openWBPro.lan","template":"openwb-pro"}

meter
---
db:11 type:template {"host":"debian-server.lan","id":1,"maxacpower":"0","modbus":"tcpip","port":"9000","template":"solaredge-hybrid","usage":"grid","watchdog":"60s"}
db:12 type:template {"capacity":9.3,"host":"debian-server.lan","id":1,"maxacpower":"0","modbus":"tcpip","port":"9000","template":"solaredge-hybrid","usage":"battery","watchdog":"60s"}
db:13 type:template {"host":"debian-server.lan","id":1,"maxacpower":4200,"modbus":"tcpip","port":"9000","template":"solaredge-hybrid","usage":"pv","watchdog":"60s"}
db:14 type:template {"host":"debian-server.lan","id":"5","maxacpower":4200,"modbus":"tcpip","port":"9000","template":"solaredge-hybrid","usage":"pv","watchdog":"60s"}
db:15 type:template {"host":"debian-server.lan","id":1,"maxacpower":4200,"modbus":"tcpip","port":"9000","template":"solaredge-hybrid","usage":"pv","watchdog":"60s"}

vehicle
---
db:16 type:template {"alternativewakeup":true,"cache":900000000000,"capacity":48,"icon":"car","identifiers":["0011810505","7C:BC:84:40:F8:C1"],"maxCurrent":32,"minCurrent":10,"mode":"pv","password":"*****","template":"renault","title":"Zoe","user":"*****","vin":"*****"}
db:17 type:template {"cache":"15m","capacity":60,"icon":"car","identifiers":["0011840806","00:7D:*"],"maxCurrent":16,"minCurrent":6,"mode":"pv","password":"*****","template":"cupra","title":"Born","user":"*****","vin":"*****"}

loadpoint
---
db:19 type: {"charger":"db:18","circuit":"garage","defaultMode":"pv","maxCurrent":32,"meter":"","minCurrent":6,"mode":"pv","phasesConfigured":0,"soc":{"estimate":true,"poll":{"interval":3600000000000,"mode":"charging"}},"thresholds":{"disable":{"delay":360000000000,"threshold":500},"enable":{"delay":360000000000,"threshold":-2100}},"title":"Pro","vehicle":""}

Log details

Bei 1p:

[lp-1 ] INFO 2025/02/22 10:26:23 start charging ->
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:23 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:23 soc estimated: 67.00% (vehicle: 67.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:23 vehicle soc: 67%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:23 vehicle range: 151km
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:23 max charge current: 32A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:37 ----
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:37 charge power: 6725W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:37 charge currents: [30 0.059 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:37 power: 6788W

[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/22 10:26:37 over current detected: 29.8A > 16A

[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 power: 6087W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 current: 23.6A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 ext 1 power: 6842W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 battery 1 power: 2918W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 grid power: 6087W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 pv 3 power: 789W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 battery 1 soc: 34%
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 pv 1 power: 788W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 pv 2 power: 1810W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 pv power: 3387W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 grid powers: [-758 5395 1599]W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 grid currents: [0 23.6 6.8]A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 site power: 9105W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:38 detected active phases: 1p
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 charge total import: 2469.411kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 charger status: C
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 soc estimated: 67.04% (vehicle: 67.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 vehicle soc: 67%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 vehicle range: 151km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 validate current: 29.8A + (32A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 18.2A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 10:26:39 max charge current: 18.2A 


Bei 3p:

[lp-1 ] INFO 2025/02/22 13:01:39 start charging ->
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 soc estimated: 67.00% (vehicle: 67.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 vehicle soc: 67%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 vehicle range: 152km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 validate current: 6.54A + (15.9A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 25.4A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 validate power: -45.326W + (0W -> 22080W) > 11000W capped at 11045W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:39 max charge current: 16A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:52 ----
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:52 charge power: 10214W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:52 charge currents: [15.4 15.4 15.5]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:52 power: 10260W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:52 current: 15.5A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 power: 6445W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 current: 14.5A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 ext 1 power: 10260W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 battery 1 power: 3719W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 battery 1 soc: 80%
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 grid power: 6416W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 pv 3 power: 938W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:53 pv 1 power: 938W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 pv 2 power: 1026W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 pv power: 2902W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 grid powers: [777 3147 2490]W
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 grid currents: [3.9 14.5 11.7]A
[site ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 site power: 10235W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 charge total import: 2469.885kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 charger status: C
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 soc estimated: 67.05% (vehicle: 67.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 vehicle soc: 67%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 vehicle range: 152km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 validate current: 15.5A + (16A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 16.5A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 validate power: 10260W + (10214W -> 22080W) > 11000W capped at 10955W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:54 max charge current: 15.9A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/22 13:01:56 set charge mode: off

What type of operating system or environment does evcc run on?

Linux

External automation

  • I have made sure that no external automation like HomeAssistant or Node-RED is active or accessing any of the mentioned devices when this issue occurs.

Nightly build

  • I have verified that the issue is reproducible with the latest nightly build

Version

v0.200.2
@andig

This comment has been minimized.

Sign in to view
@andig andig added the question Rather clarification than issue label Feb 26, 2025
@andig andig self-assigned this Feb 26, 2025
@Nasdero

This comment has been minimized.

Sign in to view
@andig

This comment has been minimized.

Sign in to view
@Nasdero

This comment has been minimized.

Sign in to view
@andig

This comment has been minimized.

Sign in to view
@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025

Es wäre super, wenn Du den Garage circuit bitte nochmal auf TRACE setzen könntest und das Log nochmal aktualisieren. Da müsste ja das Wunder passieren.

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

Es wäre super, wenn Du den Garage circuit bitte nochmal auf TRACE setzen könntest und das Log nochmal aktualisieren. Da müsste ja das Wunder passieren.

Können wir gerne machen, wird aber erst heute Nachmittag, wir helfen gerne dabei eure schon gute Software zu verbessern, hilft euch und natürlich auch uns ;) .

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

Ich hoffe, dass hier, ist was du haben möchtest:

[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:37 power: 7.748W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:37 current: 0.076A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:39 validate current: 0.076A + (15.9A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 31.8A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 13:57:39 validate power: 7.748W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:52 power: 5433.3W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 13:57:52 over current detected: 23.3A > 16A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:56 validate current: 23.3A + (31.8A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 24.5A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:57:56 validate power: 5433.3W + (0W -> 7360W) > 11000W capped at 5566.7W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:58:00 power: 6788.2W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 13:58:00 over current detected: 30.2A > 16A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:58:02 validate current: 30.2A + (29.9A -> 0A) > 16A capped at 15.7A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 13:58:02 validate power: 6788.2W + (6634.5W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:58:07 power: 8.693W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 13:58:07 current: 0.074A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 13:58:10 validate current: 0.074A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 13:58:10 validate power: 8.693W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025 

validate current: 0.076A + (15.9A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 31.8A

Das sieht sehr falsch aus

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Hast du bitte noch ein bisschen mehr Log vom Loadpoint dazu? Das Problem hier ist, dass der Circuit denke er wolle von 15.9 auf 32A schalten, tatsächlich ist das aber ein Sprung von 0.076 auf 32A. Es ist nicht erkennbar, wo die Differenz entsteht.

/cc @premultiply

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025 

[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:33 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:35 charge total import: 2515.176kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:35 charger status: B
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:48 charge power: 0W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:48 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:50 charge total import: 2515.176kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:08:50 charger status: B
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:00 set charge mode: now
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:00 charge power: 0W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:00 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:01 charge total import: 2515.176kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:01 charger status: B
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:02 max charge current: 15.9A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:02 charger enable
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:02 wake-up timer: start
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:03 charge power: 0W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:03 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:05 charge total import: 2515.176kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:05 charger status: B
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:05 max charge current: 31.9A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:18 charge power: 2156W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:18 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 charge total import: 2515.179kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 charger status: C
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 charge start energy: 2515.179kWh
[lp-1 ] INFO 2025/02/26 16:09:20 start charging ->
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 soc estimated: 64.00% (vehicle: 64.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 vehicle soc: 64%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 vehicle range: 151km
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:20 max charge current: 17.8A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:27 set charge mode: off
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:27 charge power: 3626W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:27 charge currents: [29.9 0.059 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 detected active phases: 1p
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 charge total import: 2515.191kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 charger status: C
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 soc estimated: 64.02% (vehicle: 64.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 vehicle soc: 64%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 vehicle range: 151km
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 charger disable
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:28 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:33 charge power: 3731W
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:33 charge currents: [16.7 0.059 0]A
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:35 detected active phases: 1p
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:35 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:35 charger status: B
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:35 charge final energy: 0.069kWh
[lp-1 ] INFO 2025/02/26 16:09:35 stop charging <-
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:35 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:36 soc estimated: 64.03% (vehicle: 64.00%)
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:36 vehicle soc: 64%
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:09:36 vehicle range: 151km

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025

Bitte vollständig einschl. Circuit- Danke!

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

Bitte vollständig einschl. Circuit- Danke!

Hier gerne, wir haben beide Circuits rein genommen:

[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:25 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:25 power: 12W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:25 current: 2.5A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 15.9A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:27 validate current: 2.5A + (0A -> 15.9A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:27 validate power: 8.141W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:27 validate power: 12W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 max charge current: 15.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charger enable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 wake-up timer: start
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 power: 8.141W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 current: 0.074A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:28 power: 75W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:28 current: 2.5A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:29 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:29 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:29 validate current: 0.074A + (15.9A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 31.9A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:29 validate current: 2.5A + (15.9A -> 31.9A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:29 validate power: 8.141W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:29 validate power: 75W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:29 max charge current: 31.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:39 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:39 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:40 power: 9.282W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:40 current: 3.04A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:40 power: 206W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:40 current: 2.5A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 charge start energy: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 16:36:41 start charging ->
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 soc estimated: 65.00% (vehicle: 65.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 vehicle soc: 65%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 vehicle range: 151km
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:41 validate current: 3.04A + (31.9A -> 32A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:41 validate current: 2.5A + (31.9A -> 32A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:41 validate power: 9.282W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:41 validate power: 206W + (0W -> 7360W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:41 max charge current: 32A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:54 charge power: 6587W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:54 charge currents: [29.8 0.056 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:55 power: 6747.6W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 16:36:55 over current detected: 30.1A > 16A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:55 power: 3226W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:55 current: 30.6A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 charge total import: 2515.210kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 soc estimated: 65.02% (vehicle: 65.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 vehicle soc: 65%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 vehicle range: 151km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 validate current: 30.1A + (32A -> 32A) > 16A capped at 17.9A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:56 validate current: 30.6A + (32A -> 17.9A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:56 validate power: 6747.6W + (6586.9W -> 7360W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:36:56 validate power: 3226W + (6586.9W -> 7360W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:56 max charge current: 17.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:58 set charge mode: off
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:58 charge power: 6564W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:58 charge currents: [29.9 0.056 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:58 power: 3673.4W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 16:36:58 over current detected: 17.8A > 16A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:59 power: 6809W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:59 current: 30.3A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 charge total import: 2515.219kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 soc estimated: 65.04% (vehicle: 65.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 vehicle soc: 65%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 vehicle range: 151km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 validate current: 17.8A + (29.9A -> 0A) > 16A capped at 28.1A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:00 validate current: 30.3A + (29.9A -> 28.1A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:00 validate power: 3673.4W + (6563.5W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:00 validate power: 6809W + (6563.5W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 charger disable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:00 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:09 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:09 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:10 power: 8.337W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:10 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:10 power: 173W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:10 current: 2.5A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 charger status: B
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 charge final energy: 0.031kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 16:37:11 stop charging <-
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 soc estimated: 65.06% (vehicle: 65.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 vehicle soc: 65%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:11 vehicle range: 151km
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:11 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:11 validate current: 2.5A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:11 validate power: 8.337W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:11 validate power: 173W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:24 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:24 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:25 power: 8.983W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:25 current: 0.077A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:25 power: -1002W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:25 current: 1.6A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:26 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:26 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:26 validate current: 0.077A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:26 validate current: 1.6A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:26 validate power: 8.983W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:26 validate power: -1002W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:39 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:39 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:40 power: 8.244W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:40 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:40 power: -120W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:40 current: 1.6A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:42 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:42 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:42 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:42 validate current: 1.6A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:42 validate power: 8.244W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:42 validate power: -120W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:54 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:54 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:55 power: 8.347W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:55 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:55 power: -24W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:55 current: 2.2A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:56 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:37:56 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:56 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:56 validate current: 2.2A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:56 validate power: 8.347W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:37:56 validate power: -24W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:09 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:09 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:10 power: 8.683W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:10 current: 0.077A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:10 power: 114W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:10 current: 2.2A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:11 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:11 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:11 validate current: 0.077A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:11 validate current: 2.2A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:11 validate power: 8.683W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:11 validate power: 114W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:24 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:24 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:25 power: 8.309W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:25 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:25 power: 27W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:25 current: 2.2A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:26 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:26 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:26 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:26 validate current: 2.2A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:26 validate power: 8.309W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:26 validate power: 27W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:39 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:39 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:40 power: 8.15W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:40 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:41 power: -21W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:41 current: 1.7A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:42 charge total import: 2515.228kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:38:42 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:42 validate current: 0.073A + (0A -> 0A) <= 16A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:42 validate current: 1.7A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:42 validate power: 8.15W + (0W -> 0W) <= 11000W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 16:38:42 validate power: -21W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025

Ich möchte ja nicht kleinlich sein, aber...

[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:27 charge total import: 2515.197kWh
[lp-1 ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 16:36:29 charge total import: 2515.197kWh

Du scheinst 2s Intervall zu haben. Bis dahin kann eine träge Wallbox natürlich nicht anfangen zu laden und daher funktionert auch die Begrenzung nicht.

Dazu sollte es eine sehr explizite Warnung im Log geben. Konfigurationsfehler.

@andig andig closed this as completed Feb 26, 2025
@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

Du meinst "Regelverhalten" ? Steht auf 15s.

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025

Das ist zu schnell. Deine WB hat im zweiten Zyklus trotz Freigabe noch nicht mit laden begonnen- daher werden auch die nächsten 16A akzeptiert...

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Das ist zu schnell. Deine WB hat im zweiten Zyklus trotz Freigabe noch nicht mit laden begonnen- daher werden auch die nächsten 16A akzeptiert...

Ich habe es nun mit 30s und 60s getestet. Selbes Ergebiss. Auf dem Linux Server läuft auch nur eine Instanz.

Dazu sollte es eine sehr explizite Warnung im Log geben

Warnung im LOG habe ich da auch keine zu gefunden in EVCC.

Oder meinst du "[site ] WARN 2025/02/26 20:15:00 interval <30s can lead to unexpected behavior, see https://docs.evcc.io/docs/reference/configuration/interval"? Wir haben den Hinweis in den DOCs dazu gesehen.

Wo du schreibts "Deine WB hat im zweiten Zyklus trotz Freigabe noch nicht mit laden begonnen", dachte ich, kann ja auch am ZOE liegen.
Ich habe es dann mit dem Born gestet, musste aber auf 8A runter für die Garage, er kann ja "nur" 16A, das funktioniert mal und mal nicht bei 60s. Sobald ich auf "Schnell" klicke, fängt er nach 6-7s an zu laden und trotzdem kommt "over current detected: 15.2A > 8A" fast immer.

Auf dreiphasig funktioniert es mit 15, 30 und 60s einwandfrei. Sehr merkwürdig. Da fängt der Born auch nach 6-8s zu laden an. Das sehe ich am Shelly 3em wann er lädt. Habe es mit einer Stoppuhr gemessen.

Was mir auffällt, das "charge total import" innerhalb so kurzen Abständen, passiert unregellmässig. Mitten drin sind sie in größeren Abständen. Sollten diese nicht bei einem Regelverhalten von 60s nicht auch alle ~60s kommen?

  • 19:00:32 charge total import
  • 19:00:37 charge total import
  • 19:00:37 car connected
  • 19:00:37 charge total import
  • 19:00:40 charge total import
  • 19:01:28 charge total import
  • 19:01:40 charge total import
  • 19:02:40 charge total import
  • 19:02:58 charge total import
  • 19:03:40 charge total import
  • 19:03:40 stop charging
  • 19:03:40 charge total import
  • 19:04:40 charge total import
  • 19:05:39 charge total import

Diese unregelmäßigkeiten sind auch bei 3p zu sehen,

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Ich habe es nun mit 30s und 60s getestet. Selbes Ergebiss

Logfile?

Warnung im LOG habe ich da auch keine zu gefunden in EVCC.

Die Warnung bei Interval <30s kommt direkt beim Start. Und sie tut das auch nicht ohne Grund...

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

[site ] WARN 2025/02/26 20:15:00 interval <30s can lead to unexpected behavior, see https://docs.evcc.io/docs/reference/configuration/interval

Ja die habe ich grade gesehen und in den DOCs auch, Logs mach ich dir morgen.

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Feb 26, 2025

Wie der Teufel es will, wenn man die LOGs braucht, dann funktioniert es bei 15,30 und 60s. Aber dann auf einmal ging es wieder nicht mehr.

Hier auf 60s, 8A und 5500W für Garage begrenzt, der Born braucht maximal 6-7s bis er Strom zieht nachdem ich auf "Schnell" geklickt habe:

"WARN 2025/02/26 20:44:10 over current detected: 15.5A > 8A"

[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set priority: 0
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set smart cost limit: <nil>
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set thresholds: {Enable:{Delay:6m0s Threshold:-2100} Disable:{Delay:6m0s Threshold:500}}
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set plan energy: 0kWh @ 0001-01-01 00:53:28 +0053 LMT
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set session energy limit: 0
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set session soc limit: 0
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set soc config: {Poll:{Mode:charging Interval:1h0m0s} Estimate:0xc00110655c}
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set default mode: pv
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set phases: 1
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set min current: 6
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 set max current: 32
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:06 charge total import: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:07 loadpoint 1:
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:07   mode:        off
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:07   charger:     power ✓ energy ✓ currents ✓ phases ✓ wakeup ✗
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:07   meters:      charge ✓
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:07     charge:    power ✓ energy ✓ currents ✓
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 phase timer inactive
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 pv timer inactive
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 power: 8.262W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:07 current: 0.073A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:08 power: 1065W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:08 current: 3A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charge total import: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charger status: B
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charge start energy: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:10 car connected
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle api refresh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 pv timer elapse
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 pv timer inactive
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charge total import: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charger vehicle id: 00:7D:FA:08:76:1A
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle updated: unknown -> Born
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 set charge mode: pv
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle status: A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 vehicle range: 205km
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 switched phases: 1p
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 power: 8.075W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:10 current: 0.072A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:11 power: 1064W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:11 current: 2.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 vehicle odometer: 4403km
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 charge total import: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 charger status: B
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 pv charge current: 0A = 0A + -5.06A (1164W @ 1p)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 pv enable timer reset
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:12 pv timer inactive
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:12 validate current: 0.072A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:12 validate current: 2.9A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:12 validate power: 8.075W + (0W -> 0W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:12 validate power: 1064W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:14 set charge mode: now
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:14 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:14 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:14 power: 8.3W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:14 current: 0.075A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:15 power: 1076W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:15 current: 2.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 charge total import: 2516.880kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 validate current: 0.075A + (0A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 7.92A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:16 validate current: 2.9A + (0A -> 7.92A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:16 validate power: 8.3W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:41:16 validate power: 1076W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 max charge current: 7.92A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 charger enable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:41:16 wake-up timer: start
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 set charge mode: off
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 charge power: 1690W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 charge currents: [7.54 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 power: 1714W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 current: 7.61A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 power: 2784W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:00 current: 10.1A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 charge total import: 2516.897kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 charge start energy: 2516.897kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:42:01 start charging ->
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 soc estimated: 60.00% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 vehicle range: 205km
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:01 validate current: 7.61A + (7.92A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:01 validate current: 10.1A + (7.92A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:01 validate power: 1714W + (1690.5W -> 0W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:01 validate power: 2784W + (1690.5W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 charger disable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:01 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:10 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:10 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:10 power: 8.693W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:10 current: 0.076A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:11 power: 1107W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:11 current: 2.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:12 charge total import: 2516.900kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:12 charger status: B
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:12 charge final energy: 0.003kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:42:12 stop charging <-
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:12 charge total import: 2516.900kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:13 soc estimated: 60.00% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:13 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:13 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:42:13 vehicle range: 205km
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:13 validate current: 0.076A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:13 validate current: 2.9A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:13 validate power: 8.693W + (0W -> 0W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:42:13 validate power: 1107W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:06 set charge mode: now
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:06 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:06 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:06 power: 8.393W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:06 current: 0.074A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:08 power: 1073W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:08 current: 2.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 charge total import: 2516.900kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 validate current: 0.074A + (0A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 7.93A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:11 validate current: 2.9A + (0A -> 7.93A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:11 validate power: 8.393W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:11 validate power: 1073W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 max charge current: 7.93A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 charger enable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 wake-up timer: start
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 power: 8.085W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:11 current: 0.072A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:12 power: 1046W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:12 current: 3A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:15 charge total import: 2516.900kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:15 charger status: B
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:15 validate current: 0.072A + (7.93A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 15.9A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:15 validate current: 3A + (7.93A -> 15.9A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:15 validate power: 8.085W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:43:15 validate power: 1046W + (0W -> 3680W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:15 max charge current: 15.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:10 charge power: 3447W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:10 charge currents: [15.5 0.031 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:10 power: 3488.6W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 20:44:10 over current detected: 15.5A > 8A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:12 power: 4580W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:12 current: 17.8A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 charge total import: 2516.950kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 charge start energy: 2516.950kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:44:14 start charging ->
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 soc estimated: 60.00% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 vehicle range: 205km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 validate current: 15.5A + (15.9A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.31A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:44:14 validate current: 17.8A + (15.9A -> 8.31A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:44:14 validate power: 3488.6W + (3446.8W -> 3680W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:44:14 validate power: 4580W + (3446.8W -> 3680W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:44:14 max charge current: 8.31A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:10 charge power: 1776W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:10 charge currents: [7.94 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:10 power: 1801.7W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 20:45:10 over current detected: 8.02A > 8A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:12 power: 2859W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:12 current: 10.6A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 detected active phases: 1p
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 charge total import: 2516.984kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 soc estimated: 60.06% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 vehicle range: 205km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 validate current: 8.02A + (8.31A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.29A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:15 validate current: 10.6A + (8.31A -> 8.29A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:15 validate power: 1801.7W + (1776.1W -> 3680W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:15 validate power: 2859W + (1776.1W -> 3680W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 max charge current: 8.29A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 set charge mode: off
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 charge power: 1776W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 charge currents: [7.94 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:15 power: 1801W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/02/26 20:45:15 over current detected: 8.02A > 8A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:17 power: 2840W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:17 current: 10.5A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 detected active phases: 1p
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 charge total import: 2516.987kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 charger status: C
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 soc estimated: 60.06% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 vehicle range: 205km
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 validate current: 8.02A + (8.29A -> 0A) > 8A capped at 8.27A
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:21 validate current: 10.5A + (8.29A -> 8.27A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:21 validate power: 1801W + (1776.2W -> 0W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:45:21 validate power: 2840W + (1776.2W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 charger disable
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:45:21 wake-up timer: stop
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:10 charge power: 0W
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:10 charge currents: [0 0 0]A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:10 power: 8.225W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:10 current: 0.074A
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:12 power: 1074W
[circuit-main] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:12 current: 2.9A
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:15 charge total import: 2516.991kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:15 charger status: B
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:15 charge final energy: 0.044kWh
[lp-1  ] INFO 2025/02/26 20:46:15 stop charging <-
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:15 charge total import: 2516.991kWh
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:16 soc estimated: 60.07% (vehicle: 60.00%)
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:16 vehicle soc: 60%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:16 vehicle soc limit: 100%
[lp-1  ] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:46:16 vehicle range: 206km
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:46:16 validate current: 0.074A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:46:16 validate current: 2.9A + (0A -> 0A) <= 50A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:46:16 validate power: 8.225W + (0W -> 0W) <= 5500W ok
[circuit-main] TRACE 2025/02/26 20:46:16 validate power: 1074W + (0W -> 0W) <= 34000W ok

@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 26, 2025

Bevor ich mich wieder einlese- hast du geschaut obs die gleiche Ursache hat?

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

mfuchs1984 commented Feb 26, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Insgesamt sieht es nach 60 Sekunden interval aus, aber zwischendurch wird innerhalb von 5 Sekunden mehrmals agiert. Das liegt wohl daran:

  • im Hintergrund läuft das 60 Sekunden interval
  • aber einige Aktionen, wie setmode führen zu einem unmittelbaren Loadpoint update

    evcc/core/loadpoint_api.go

    Line 112 in 714438d

    lp.requestUpdate()

Das Loadpoint update löst aus, dass ein charge current von 7,x Ampere freigegeben wird, nur 4 Sekunden später schlägt das normale interval zu. Es wird von 7,x vorher ausgegangen, der circuit Strom liegt aber noch bei 8-7,x, da innerhalb von 4 Sekunden natürlich die Ladung noch nicht gestartet ist. Die Berechnung

evcc/core/circuit/circuit.go

Line 342 in 714438d

potential := maxCurrent - c.current
geht also davon aus, dass noch knapp 8 Ampere mehr möglich sind.

Das Log zeigt das Problem sehr plakativ
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/02/26 20:43:15 validate current: 0.072A + (7.93A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 15.9A
-> das limit liegt bei 8, aber gecappt wird bei 15.9, also fast dem doppelten Strom.

Gibt's einen Grund, warum old, also die vorher freigegeben charge power, überhaupt mit einbezogen wird? Sollte man nicht dem circuit Meter vertrauen und hart beim limit bzw. potential statt old+potential abregeln?

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

mfuchs1984 commented Feb 27, 2025 •
edited
Loading

@andig @premultiply wenn ich nicht ganz falsch mit meiner Analyse im vorherigen Kommentar liege, sollte man das wieder öffnen.
Mit der jetzigen Implementierung steigt der freigegebene Ladestrom mit jedem Aufruf von ValidateCurrent um den vorher freigegebenen, aber (noch) nicht genutzten Ladestrom (auch wenn bswp. das Auto die Ladung noch nicht startet) und ist dann sofort oberhalb der Grenze des circuits, nahezu beim doppelten im ersten Schritt. Da das auch außerhalb des Intervals passieren kann (z.B. nach Wechsel des Lademodus), passiert das in den Logs hier ziemlich oft.
Wenn man stattdessen nur auf potential schaut, und nicht den vorher freigegebenen aber noch nicht genutzen Strom dazu zählt, passiert das nicht mehr, es wird dann immer maximal "max_circuit_current - current_circuit current" freigegeben, also das was wirklich genutzt werden darf. Das selbe Problem besteht bei der power validation.

@andig andig reopened this Feb 27, 2025
@andig
Copy link
Member

andig commented Feb 27, 2025 •
edited
Loading

Das Loadpoint update löst aus, dass ein charge current von 7,x Ampere freigegeben wird, nur 4 Sekunden später schlägt das normale interval zu. Es wird von 7,x vorher ausgegangen, der circuit Strom liegt aber noch bei 8-7,x, da innerhalb von 4 Sekunden natürlich die Ladung noch nicht gestartet ist.

Grossartige Analyse, danke!

Gibt's einen Grund, warum old, also die vorher freigegeben charge power, überhaupt mit einbezogen wird? Sollte man nicht dem circuit Meter vertrauen und hart beim limit bzw. potential statt old+potential abregeln?

Die Idee ist, dass old->new der Sprung ist der mit der Änderung gemacht wird. Hintergrund ist, dass viele Fahrzeuge unterhalb der Freigabe bleiben. In dem Fall den Istwert als "old" zu nehmen würde das LM unnötig strikt machen. Hier funktioniert das aufgrund der Zeitkonstante aber nicht. Also was geht:

  • der Sicherung vertrauen
  • wie vorgeschlagen ändern (mit allen Nebenwirkungen)
  • dito, aber mit irgendeiner Fallunterscheidung ob Echtwert oder theoretisches Delta (oder min(echt, theoretisch))
  • Ladepunkte nicht mehr außerhalb des Intervalls aktualisieren (das merken die User sofort)

/cc @premultiply

@andig andig added the enhancement New feature or request label Feb 27, 2025
@andig andig removed the stale Outdated and ready to close label Mar 21, 2025
@mfuchs1984 mfuchs1984 mentioned this issue Mar 27, 2025
Merged
@github-actions github-actions bot added the stale Outdated and ready to close label Mar 28, 2025
@github-actions github-actions bot closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale Apr 2, 2025
@andig andig reopened this Apr 2, 2025
@andig andig removed the stale Outdated and ready to close label Apr 2, 2025
@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Wäre vermutlich gut, wenn das jemand im nightly testen könnte :)

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 3, 2025

Wäre vermutlich gut, wenn das jemand im nightly testen könnte :)

Wenn ich nacher Zeit habe, teste ich das kurz.

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Das nightly ist noch nicht verfügbar.

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Jetzt ist es da

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 3, 2025

Jetzt ist es da

Sieht soweit gut aus, bei 16A maxCurrent, wird dem EV 15,7A angeboten. Ich habe es mit 1p und 3p getestet, bei 3p scheint der Startwert geringer zu sein und geht dann hoch auf die ca. 16A, für mich ok.

Besten Dank für die Mühe.

Wenn ich das richtig mitbekommen habe, erlaubt ihr 10% über dem Limit, dann sollte man evntuell bei der Überprüfung die 10% auch beachten, denke ich.

Image

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Die 10% sind gerade noch in Diskussion.

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Kannst du von deinen Beobachtungen ein Log mit dem circuit auf trace machen?

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 3, 2025

Kannst du von deinen Beobachtungen ein Log mit dem circuit auf trace machen?

Schwierig, beide EVs voll, zuviel 🌞, Morgen kann ich mit dem Born testen.

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 3, 2025

Kannst du von deinen Beobachtungen ein Log mit dem circuit auf trace machen?

Warum auch immer, es wurde kurz auf PV geladen, Sonne war keine da, aber egal.

Ich habe dann auf Schnell umgestellt, 8A Limit am Zähler, siehst ja wo es losgeht. Wenn du noch etwas brauchst, einfach melden.

[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:35:50 validate current: 4.48A + (6A -> 6A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:35:50 validate power: 1094.4W + (0W -> 1380W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:35:57 power: 1366.6W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:35:57 current: 5.95A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:35:58 validate current: 5.95A + (6A -> 6A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:35:58 validate power: 1366.6W + (1313.3W -> 1380W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:12 power: 1372.3W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:12 current: 5.97A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:13 validate current: 5.97A + (6A -> 6A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:13 validate power: 1372.3W + (1313.3W -> 1380W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:27 power: 1366.5W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:27 current: 5.95A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:28 validate current: 5.95A + (6A -> 6A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:28 validate power: 1366.5W + (1313.4W -> 1380W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:33 power: 1366.7W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:33 current: 5.95A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:34 validate current: 5.95A + (6A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:36:34 validate power: 1366.7W + (1313.4W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:42 power: 42.856W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:42 current: 0.269A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:57 power: 42.94W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:36:57 current: 0.271A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:01 power: 43.043W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:01 current: 0.271A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:12 power: 1681.5W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:12 current: 7.34A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:13 validate current: 7.34A + (7.73A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.39A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:37:13 validate power: 1681.5W + (1624.5W -> 3680W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:27 power: 1862.3W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/04/03 19:37:27 over current detected: 8.1A > 8A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:28 validate current: 8.1A + (8.39A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.29A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:37:28 validate power: 1862.3W + (1802.8W -> 3680W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:42 power: 1815W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:42 current: 7.88A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:43 validate current: 7.88A + (8.29A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.42A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:37:43 validate power: 1815W + (1754.9W -> 3680W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:57 power: 1863.1W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/04/03 19:37:57 over current detected: 8.06A > 8A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:37:58 validate current: 8.06A + (8.42A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.35A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:37:58 validate power: 1863.1W + (1801.9W -> 3680W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:38:12 power: 1863.5W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/04/03 19:38:12 over current detected: 8.07A > 8A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:38:13 validate current: 8.07A + (8.35A -> 16A) > 8A capped at 8.28A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:38:13 validate power: 1863.5W + (1802W -> 3680W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:38:15 power: 1863.6W
[circuit-garage] WARN 2025/04/03 19:38:15 over current detected: 8.07A > 8A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/03 19:38:17 validate current: 8.07A + (8.28A -> 0A) > 8A capped at 0A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/03 19:38:17 validate power: 1863.6W + (1802W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Danke, das ist super hilfreich.

@andig andig mentioned this issue Apr 4, 2025
Closed
@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Bitte mit dem nächsten nightly (ist noch nicht verfügbar) nochmal testen, die Warnungen sollten damit verschwinden.

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 4, 2025

Bitte mit dem nächsten nightly (ist noch nicht verfügbar) nochmal testen, die Warnungen sollten damit verschwinden.

Werde ich machen, ich hab extra den Born auf 90% begrenzt, sonst ist er gleich wieder voll, immer diese Sonne ;).

Wo ihr im Thema so tief drin seid.

Würde das auch funktionieren wenn ich z.B. auf L2 mit der openWB pro und auf L3 mit dem go-e laden würde?
Oder mit 3p mit der openWB und mit 1p auf L3 mit dem go-e?

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Heute kannst du gerne nochmal mit dem nightly build spielen.

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 6, 2025

Heute kannst du gerne nochmal mit dem nightly build spielen.

[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:25 power: 9.385W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:25 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:28 power: 9.432W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:28 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:29 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:29 validate power: 9.432W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:33 power: 9.385W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:33 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:35 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 20A) > 8A capped at 7.94A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:35 validate power: 9.385W + (0W -> 4600W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:43 power: 10.012W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:43 current: 0.064A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:49 validate current: 0.064A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:49 validate power: 10.012W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:58 power: 1698.5W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:58 current: 7.45A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:03:59 validate current: 7.45A + (7.94A -> 20A) > 8A capped at 8A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:03:59 validate power: 1698.5W + (1677.6W -> 4600W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:13 power: 1743.2W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:13 current: 7.64A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:14 validate current: 7.64A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:14 validate power: 1743.2W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:28 power: 1743.3W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:28 current: 7.65A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:29 validate current: 7.65A + (8A -> 20A) > 8A capped at 8A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:29 validate power: 1743.3W + (1721.8W -> 4600W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:43 power: 1742.9W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:43 current: 7.65A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:44 validate current: 7.65A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:44 validate power: 1742.9W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:58 power: 1742.6W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:58 current: 7.64A
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:04:59 validate current: 7.64A + (8A -> 20A) > 8A capped at 8A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:04:59 validate power: 1742.6W + (1721.9W -> 4600W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:13 power: 1742.7W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:13 current: 7.64A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:16 validate current: 7.64A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:16 validate power: 1742.7W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:20 power: 1742.8W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:20 current: 7.64A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:21 validate current: 7.64A + (8A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:21 validate power: 1742.8W + (1721.8W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:28 power: 9.554W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:28 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:31 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:31 validate power: 9.554W + (1721.8W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:43 power: 9.9W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:43 current: 0.067A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:44 validate current: 0.067A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:05:44 validate power: 9.9W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:58 power: 9.582W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:05:58 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:04 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:04 validate power: 9.582W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:06:13 power: 9.526W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:06:13 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:17 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:17 validate power: 9.526W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:06:28 power: 9.301W
[circuit-garage] DEBUG 2025/04/06 08:06:28 current: 0.062A
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:29 validate current: 0.062A + (0A -> 0A) <= 8A ok
[circuit-garage] TRACE 2025/04/06 08:06:29 validate power: 9.301W + (0W -> 0W) <= 22000W ok

@mfuchs1984
Copy link
Contributor

Super 👍

@premultiply
Copy link
Member

"22 kW" (3 mal 32 A) sind übrigens 22080 W, nicht 22000 W ☝️😇

@Nasdero
Copy link
Author

Nasdero commented Apr 6, 2025 •
edited
Loading

"22 kW" (3 mal 32 A) sind übrigens 22080 W, nicht 22000 W ☝️😇

Echt jetzt? Wie kommst du dadrauf, gehen wir einmal von genau 400V aus und einen Leistungsfaktor von 1, dann sind 400V*32A*1,73*1= 22144W oder 400V*32A*1,73205080757 = 22170,250336896W ;)

Aktuell habe ich 415V anliegen, also 415V*32A*1,73 = 22985W ☝️😇

Nur so am Rande, was soll ich den nun eintragen?

@premultiply
Copy link
Member

Phasennennspannung ist 230V * 32A pro Phase * 3 Phasen sind 22080VA, also 22,08kVA.

Jetzt aber genug OT. 😅

@mfuchs1984 mfuchs1984 mentioned this issue Apr 19, 2025
Closed
mfuchs1984 added a commit to mfuchs1984/evcc that referenced this issue Apr 20, 2025
@mfuchs1984
Loadpoint: pass actual charge current instead of offered current to c…
4a4d92d 
…ircuit.ValidateCurrent as intended, fixes evcc-io#19166
@mfuchs1984 mfuchs1984 mentioned this issue Apr 20, 2025
Merged
@andig andig mentioned this issue Apr 21, 2025
Merged
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@andig andig

@premultiply premultiply

Labels
enhancement New feature or request
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
4 participants
@andig @premultiply @Nasdero @mfuchs1984