PTM215ZE (Zigbee Green Power) only works a few minutes #26226
Comments
This happens as you did not strictly follow the pairing procedure. As you are trying to pair a PTM215ZE and as you are using the Enocean app, I would use this app as well for the pairing. It is really much easier.
Otherwise, strictly follow the pairing instruction there.
Dongle-P works as coordinator or router with the right firmware. I just had a try on a test network and it is working fine... I waited approx 10 mins before clicking on an other button... |
|
Hi, lets recap for myself: If its probably the solution to get e ZGP Router, than you can ignore the rest of the reply I used a second Zigbee Stick: Conbee 3 on another Pi with Phoscon + HA on another PC (inside Proxmox). There i had no Problems to connect using the Enocean app. But i dont like to have another instance for Zigbee stuff. -> So, PTM215ZE is working fine Because it worked with that stick, I used the Conbee3 with a fresh Raspberry (3B) installation + Z2M (switched Z2m + PTM251ZE back to channel 11 to avoid problems with the existing Zigbee network). This time, it also seems to be connected but i get a different error ` ` |
|
Well, according to the documentation, https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/guide/adapters/deconz.html There are several threads opened with various errors in regard of ZGP devices. The problem here is not the stick but the implementation in the software. Definitely, I would use either TI chip ( zstack: you must use a router to translate ember: normally, you may pair a ZGP device directly to the coordinator |
|
Hi, thank you. After reading your replies with the documentation it worked immediately:
Still using Dongle-P but got a Ikea E1702 or so from a friend. I paired the Ikea outlet to my zigbee network. After this, I enabled pairing (not to all or to the coordinator -> pairing to the ikea outlet) Then I used the Enocean tool to start pairing and pressed a button. The PTM215ZE appeared immediately and still work since a few hours. Now I have to figure out how to implement this into Home Assistant. HA sees the switch, but only Link Quality and last seen is visible. No button entry shows, I cant even see a Message under /homeassistant topic Probably i have to use NodeRed.. e.g. i try this as a starting point: But.. Sometimes i feels like messages arent transmitted even when a loud "click" of the switch suggest a successful press - maybe when i press too quickly? |
|
Would you mind leave this thread open? I now have some requests and suggestions for you... Working blueprint for your PTM215Z/ZE (made by myself with the help of the HA community. This is what I use.) https://github.com/chris-1243/HA---Blueprint As you were able to sniff your trafic, would it be possible to check if the IKEA E1702 is used in If paired as |
|
Hi, of course I can. Playing around with Wireshark maybe gets useful one day: Add Filter to Wireshark for Zigbee Green Power only: "zbee_nwk_gp" Second Screenshot: Probably i have to do a "force remove" (like mentioned here #20589) before I do a new pairing. I will wait with that step, maybe you want to have another wireshark output or so. For the
( Filter? zbee_nwk_gp.endpoint==242) i dont see anything - only on paring mode? I tried your blueprint yesterday and it worked right away
|
|
I should have been a bit more precise, my apologize. Could you apply simple filter
Click on it and expend the field
If you may send a screenshot like above, it would be awesome. When you pair your device, it is really important to select a specific router. In your case, the IKEA E1702. Select The cluster might be seen in the device tab in Z2M frontend |
|
Hi, sadly, there is absolutely no output when appyling the filter "zbee_zcl" and press some button. As i read your posts I would have expected a Input Cluster for ZGP* Screenshot 1: Cluster ot the E1703 (was wrong with E1702 *: maybe not close enough) ** Also these outlet have the "same" clusters: Nous A1Z, Aquara SP-EUC01 - just for the case I should try them instead
|
|
E1703? This does not exist in Z2M database. Maybe you meant E1603? Anyway, this device should translate ZGP frames as In Wireshark, have you added your network key? It is in Edit --> Preferences --> Protocols --> Zigbee --> edit. Without this, you will not be able to decode completely the traffic.
As it seems you are still in
If you may check with these outlet, it would be great. My goal is to add more routers in Zigbee2mqtt.io documentation |
|
Hi, never wanted to dive that deep... :-) Screenshot 1: This time with the cluster library frame: 0x7444 Ikea E1703 (really, atleast its whats printed on the device, see below). If its the wrong device, maybe also adding a information that this device doenst work for sure?
|
|
Ok, there are plenty model numbers of this device. They all share the same modelID.... https://zigbee.blakadder.com/Ikea_E1603.html According to your last screenshot, your device is paired in In order to test other outlet, you must completely remove your PTM215ZE and pair it directly to the new router and check Wireshark output.... |
|
Hi, i remove them with "force" and do even a reboot for whatever reason. E.g. with the NOUS A1Z 0x073A (selected to pair with), it states that paring was successful. It also works until i disable paring mode. But after that, it doenst work inside Z2M. Strange (for me) is, that something appears inside Wireshark (Screenshot 1). Screenshot 2 I I can help out with any testing on these devices? Thanks for your support
|
|
Below, what you do not want to see. This is what is happening when you pair such device as
Yes
No, you do not need to worry about... If you always need your IKEA plug to translate, it might tell us your other plug are not doing the job. Maybe, the firmware implementation is not done correctly. There are some known issues in Philips firmware where messages are always sent as You may keep testing your lights/plugs and if you find some able to translate ZGP frames, just let us know or you may edit the documentation in zigbee2mqtt.io... I am honestly trying to improve the documentation and help people getting these devices working as much as possible. |
|
Hi, i just tried a Conbee 3 Stick with a Outlet "Nous A1Z" which i received a few days ago. I also installed it on a "new" Raspberry installation and I resetted the PTM215Z (so it is Channel 11)
It work even when pairing is disabled since 2 hours Next try: using the "old" Nous A1Z on the new Raspberry/Z2M Installation -> New and old one is plugged in -> PTM215 Works without repairing or so Conclusion.. Nous A1Z can work, but I am not able to distinguish between good and bad
|
|
Well, it is a Tuya bases device and Zigbee standard is not well followed by this brand unfortunately. Thanks for trying 👍 |
What happened?
I bought a Enocean PTM215ZE to try a these devices. After having some trouble to pair them, finally the device appeared. And worked for some minutes.
Afther these few minutes, the device is still visible in Z2M, but doenst react anymore.
When i use a second Stick (Conbee2) with ZShark + Wireshark on a different PC, i still see that data is transmitted when pressing a button
If I just do a tail -f on the current log file(debug enabled, on the raspberry) nothing appears when pressing a button
I used this firmware:
Z-Stack_3.x.0_coordinator_20240710/CC1352P2_CC2652P_launchpad_coordinator_20240710.zip
Update:
Found this after a while -> switch works of z2m is in pairing mode. If pairing Mode is off - it stop working:
#14198 (comment)
Update 2:
I am lost:
Update 3:
SAm I wright -> Sonoff Dongle P doenst work as a coordinator?
What did you expect to happen?
No response
How to reproduce it (minimal and precise)
remove it from Z2M (including force remove)
reset the device using the Enocean app (NFC)
Pair again
-> doesnt react to button press after few minutes
Zigbee2MQTT version
2.1.0
Adapter firmware version
20240710
Adapter
Sonoff Dongle Plus P ZStack
Setup
Standalone Raspberry 3B
Debug log
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: